Is Effy Jewelry Overpriced? (Brand, Quality + More)

Is Effy Jewelry Overpriced

Lindsey, do you know if Effy jewelry is overpriced? This is one of the questions our readers ask a lot. Well, we´ve got you covered.

When you’re looking for jewelry, you want to find gorgeous, elegant pieces, but at good prices. And with any purchase, you want to know that you’re getting the best value for your dollar, no matter where you’re purchasing from.

Effy’s jewelry is known as a supplier of high quality jewelry with intricate designs, flawless craftsmanship, and hand-selected stones. Reviews for Effy Jewelry are mixed, however, with some people praising their excellent work, and others saying they’re overpriced.

We’ll explore Effy quality, compositions, and reviews here.

Is Effy Jewelry Overpriced?

This is a complex question that requires looking at several factors, such as:

– Their prices

– The metal content and stones that are used

– The comparison between their prices and metals with other jewelers

Popular opinion is also a factor to take into account.

Read also >> Is Effy Jewelry Good Quality? (Review + More)

Read also >> Are Effy Diamonds Certified? (All You Need to Know)

How Is Effy Jewelry Reviewed and Viewed?

Effy has a long history as a United States producer of fine jewelry. For the last 30 years, they’ve worked out of New York to produce amazing jewelry with handcrafted pieces and hand-picked precious stones.

Different forums have different reviews in regard to the results.

HighYa Clothing and Fashion:

HighYa Clothing and Fashion gives Effy an Overall Rating of 2.2

The general consensus on the 1-star reviews is that there’s a tendency for stones to come loose, and some difficulty in getting repairs made. These reviews offer the opinion that Effy Jewelry is definitely overpriced.

The 5-star reviews agree that the designs are elegant, the pieces are well made, and they last very well. Many 5-star buyers consider the prices charged for Effy jewelry reasonable for the detail and materials used.

Trustpilot – Jewelry Designer:

Trustpilot gives Effy an Overall Rating of 4.6

Reviewers agree that they have excellent quality and variety. The jewelry is often described as intricate and elegant.

The few lower reviews seem to involve customer service, shipping times, and the occasional necessary return, rather than the quality of the jewelry itself. Reviews:

Jewelpost reports that Effy has a 2 star review overall, with some customers reporting the styles are elegant and amazing.

Other customers say the jewelry has a tendency to lose stones, sometimes even with proper care and handling.

Other Reviews:

Here’s a sample of other reviews.

Yelp Reviews: Rated Effy at 2 Stars

Better Business Bureau: Rated Effy at 2 Stars

In short, there seems to be an overall sense that Effy jewelry has some room to improve.

Effy Materials and Price Ranges:

Effy uses precious metals and precious stones in all their designs and production.  Their lines involve materials such as:


– 14 karat gold (58% pure gold alloy)

– 18 karat gold (75% pure gold alloy)

– Sterling Silver (usually at least 92.5% pure silver alloy)


Effy uses over two dozen types of gemstones, including

– Sapphires

– Rubies

– Diamonds (usually less than 1 total carat weight)

– Emeralds

– Amethyst

And More!

Price Ranges For Effy Jewelry:

Effy Jewelry runs a huge price range, from

– 14 karat gold and tanzanite earrings for $95


– 14 karat White Gold and Diamond (12 Total Carat Weight) Tennis Bracelet for $33,475

How Do Effy Prices Compare to Other Jewelers?

A basic Effy Sterling Silver Box Link Bracelet ranges in price between $135 and $195, depending on the design.

– A similar design made by John Hardy is between $295 and $450

– A similar design by Tiffany & Co. costs about $375

A basic Effy 14 karat yellow gold 2mm Cable Chain is priced about $379.

– A similar design from Zales is about $150

– A similar design from Kay Jewelers is about $120

– A similar design from James Allen is about $307

A basic Effy 18 karat White Gold Diamond Solitaire Ring is priced at about $12,950

– a similar design from Jared (The Galleria) is priced around $3,600

– a similar design from Zales is priced around $5,300

– a similar design from Kay Jewelers is priced around $2,000

– a similar design from James Allen is priced around $5,595

Points About the Comparison:

These are price comparisons for items that are billed as 100% gold alloy or sterling silver, rather than plated pieces or vermeil.

Designer jewelry crosses a wide range of styles and compositions that can make comparisons difficult.

Different prices are influenced by the types of stones, the quality of stones, the way the stones are sourced, the size of the stones, and how they are cut.

Different alloys also alter the price, as well as the intricacy of the metalwork. Intricate metal work takes more time and labor, which adds to the final cost of the finished piece.

So does the amount of metal used. Gold is priced by the ounce, so the higher the gold content, the higher the price.

So How Do Effy Prices Compare?

When it comes to the sterling silver end of the spectrum – at least for plain metal without stones – Effy seems to be on the lower end of the price spectrum, making it some of the more affordable sterling silver jewelry out there.

When it comes to the lines with 14 karat gold in simple designs, Effy seems to run on the high end of the price range, but not unbelievably so.

When it comes to the 18 karat gold jewelry, even the simple piece with a single diamond, Effy is much higher in price than most of their well-known competitors.

While some of that may be the designs and the hand-crafting, it is still somewhat of a barrier to potential sales.


James Allen is the leader in online diamond sales. Their imaging technology is the same as inspecting a diamond with a jeweler's loupe. They have the largest exclusive loose diamond inventory online and fantastic prices.

They also have the nicest collection of lab created diamonds online. Save 10% off select lab grown diamonds and 25% off ring settings during limited time sale!


  • No questions asked returns within 30 days of shipment. James Allen will send you a paid shipping label to return the ring.
  • Lifetime Warranty
  • Free International Shipping
  • Free prong tightening, repolishing, rhodium plating and cleaning every 6 months
  • Provide insurance appraisals
  • One free resizing within 60 days of purchase
  • Free ring inscriptions
  • Best-in-class high quality imagery of all diamonds in stock
  • 24/7 Customer Service
  • Best-in-class packaging

Final Thoughts

Effy Jewelry is known for high quality and hand-crafted jewelry with gorgeous designs and all authentic stones and pure gold or sterling silver alloys.

Not all their prices are high for the type of jewelry they supply, but many reviewers say they overcharge for the quality of service and production they offer, and they may need to improve in some areas before their overall selection and service match up with the prices they charge.



Lindsey graduated with an MBA in 2009. Since then, Lindsey has worked in the retail and consumer service industry as a manager, advisor, and marketer. Lindsey is also the head writer and Co-founder of Lindsey is based in Morgantown, West Virginia.

Recent Posts

error: Content is protected !!